CBS News
Arrests made after American woman dies in controversial “suicide capsule” in Switzerland
Police in northern Switzerland said Tuesday that several people have been detained and a criminal case opened in connection with the suspected death of a person in a “suicide capsule.”
The “Sarco” capsule, which has never been used before, is presumably designed to allow a person sitting in a reclining seat inside to push a button that injects nitrogen gas into the sealed chamber. The person is then supposed to fall asleep and die by suffocation in a few minutes.
Exit International, an assisted suicide group based in the Netherlands, said it is behind the 3D-printed device that cost over $1 million to develop.
Swiss law allows assisted suicide so long as the person takes his or her life with no “external assistance” and those who help the person die do not do so for “any self-serving motive,” according to a government website.
A law firm informed prosecutors in Schaffhausen canton that an “assisted suicide” involving the Sarco had taken place Monday near a forest cabin in Merishausen, regional police said in a statement, adding that “several people” were taken into custody and prosecutors opened an investigation on suspicion of incitement and accessory to suicide.
Dutch newspaper Volkskrant reported Tuesday that police had detained one of its photographers who wanted to take pictures of the use of the Sarco. It said Schaffhausen police had indicated the photographer was being held at a police station but declined to give a further explanation.
The newspaper declined to comment further when contacted by the Associated Press.
Schaffhausen’s public prosecutor Peter Sticher told Swiss newspaper Blick that several people were arrested “so that they were not colluding with each other or covering up evidence.”
Sticher said the operators knew the risks of being arrested.
“We warned them in writing. We said that if they came to Schaffhausen and used Sarco, they would face criminal consequences,” he said.
In an email, the Dutch Foreign Ministry told the AP that it was in contact with the newspaper and Swiss officials.
“As always, we cannot interfere in the legal process of another country. At the same time, the Netherlands stands firmly for press freedom. It is very important that journalists worldwide can do their work freely,” it said.
Exit International, the group behind the Sarco, said in a statement a 64-year-old woman from the U.S. Midwest – it did not specify further – who had suffered from “severe immune compromise” had died Monday afternoon near the German border using the Sarco device.
It said Florian Willet, co-president of The Last Resort, a Swiss affiliate of Exit International, was the only person present and described her death as “peaceful, fast and dignified.”
Dr. Philip Nitschke, an Australian-born trained doctor behind Exit International, has previously told the AP that his organization received advice from lawyers in Switzerland that the use of the Sarco would be legal in the country.
In the Exit International statement on Tuesday, Nitschke said he was “pleased that the Sarco had performed exactly as it had been designed … to provide an elective, non-drug, peaceful death at the time of the person’s choosing.”
The claims of Nitschke and Exit International could not be independently verified.
On Monday, Health Minister Elisabeth Baume-Schneider was asked in Swiss parliament about the legal conditions for the use of the Sarco capsule, and suggested its use would not be legal.
“On one hand, it does not fulfill the demands of the product safety law, and as such, must not be brought into circulation,” she said. “On the other hand, the corresponding use of nitrogen is not compatible with the article on purpose in the chemicals law.”
In July, Blick reported that Sticher, the state prosecutor in Schaffhausen, wrote to Exit International’s lawyers saying any operator of the suicide capsule could face criminal proceedings if it was used there – and any conviction could bring up to five years in prison.
Prosecutors in other Swiss regions have also indicated that the use of the suicide capsule could lead to prosecution.
Over the summer, a 54-year-old U.S. woman with multiple health ailments had planned to be the first person to use the device, but those plans were abandoned.
Switzerland is among the only countries in the world where foreigners can travel to legally end their lives and has a number of organizations that are dedicated to helping people kill themselves. But unlike others, including the Netherlands, Switzerland does not allow euthanasia, which involves healthcare practitioners killing patients with a lethal injection at their request and in specific circumstances.
About 1,300 people died by assisted suicide in Switzerland in 2020, the BBC reported.
Some lawmakers in Switzerland have argued that the law is unclear and have sought to close what they call legal loopholes.
In 2021, Daniel Huerlimann, a legal expert and assistant professor at the University of St Gallen, was asked by Sarco to explore whether the use of the suicide pod would break any Swiss laws.
He told the BBC that his findings suggested the pod “did not constitute a medical device,” so would not be covered by the Swiss Therapeutic Products Act.
He also believed it would not fall foul of laws governing the use of nitrogen, weapons or product safety, the BBC reported.
“This means that the pod is not covered by Swiss law,” he said.
—-
If you or someone you know is in emotional distress or a suicidal crisis, you can reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline by calling or texting 988. You can also chat with the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline here.
For more information about mental health care resources and support, The National Alliance on Mental Illness (NAMI) HelpLine can be reached Monday through Friday, 10 a.m.–10 p.m. ET, at 1-800-950-NAMI (6264) or email info@nami.org.
The Swiss government refers queries about suicide prevention to a group called “Dargebotene Hand,” or The Offered Hand.
CBS News
Beyoncé nominated for 11 Grammys
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
CBS News
Nov 8: CBS News 24/7, 1pm ET
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
CBS News
4 smart home equity moves to make now that the Fed cut rates again
While another Federal Reserve rate cut issued this week won’t be great for savers accustomed to earning high returns on their money, it will provide another boost to borrowers. Whether you were considering a mortgage, a personal loan or even just a credit card, a reduction to the federal funds rate helps, even if the amount of assistance will vary depending on the product.
One way it will help, perhaps in a significant fashion, however, is with home equity loans and home equity lines of credit (HELOCs). Because the home serves as collateral in these borrowing exchanges, rates on both items tend to be lower than other credit options. And with rate cuts now issued twice in the last three months, they’re poised to become even less expensive.
Still, home equity borrowing comes with some inherent risks, too. And borrowers should do all they can to avoid them. As such, there are some smart home equity moves to make now that the Fed has cut rates again. Below, we’ll break down four of them.
Start by seeing what home equity loan rate you could qualify for here.
4 smart home equity moves to make now that the Fed cut rates again
Rate cuts offer prospective home equity borrowers a unique chance to capitalize on their accumulated home equity, but they should approach this chance in a strategic and nuanced way. Specifically, they should consider the following moves now:
Monitor certain dates
If you opened a home equity loan at the start of this week and didn’t wait for the Fed to take action then you likely made a mistake. While the difference in rates over a few days was likely minor, every little bit helps, particularly when spread over an extended repayment period. It’s critical to monitor certain dates — like those surrounding a Fed rate cut or the next inflation report release — for opportunities to capitalize and to lock in a below-average rate. Fortunately, there are multiple upcoming dates in which borrowers can take advantage. But this will require a proactive approach and you’ll need to have your documentation ready and credit score in top shape to truly take advantage.
Explore your current home equity borrowing options online today.
Consider a HELOC over a home equity loan
A HELOC has a variable interest rate subject to drop now that the Fed has embarked on its new rate-cutting campaign. A home equity loan, meanwhile, has a fixed interest rate that will need to be refinanced in the future to exploit any rate declines. In today’s evolving rate climate, then, it’s worth considering a HELOC over a home equity loan, even if the latter’s current rate is slightly better than the former. Plus, HELOC rates will change independently each month on their own while home equity loan borrowers will need to pay closing costs to refinance their rates.
Don’t overborrow
It’s been a long time since rates were cut (September’s reduction was the first in more than four years). So it can be tempting to overborrow now that rates appear to be moving in the right direction. But that’s always a mistake, particularly when using your home equity. So avoid that temptation and crunch the numbers to make sure you’re only borrowing an amount that you can easily afford to repay.
Open it before the end of the year
Not sure if you should wait for home equity rates to fall further into 2025? If you’re planning on using the home equity for a home improvement project, you may want to open it before the end of the year, even with the possibility of additional rate cuts high right now. That’s because the interest on both home equity loans and HELOCs is tax-deductible if used for qualifying home repairs. If you wait until 2025, however, you’ll postpone this critical tax deduction until it comes time to file your return again in 2026. So consider opening it now, then, to position yourself for potential (and immediate) tax relief.
Learn more about your home equity loan options here.
The bottom line
Now could be a great time to access your home equity, with two rate cuts already issued this year and others likely in the near future. Borrowers should still take a smart approach, however. That involves monitoring certain calendar dates for opportunities to capitalize on a lower rate, considering a HELOC over a home equity loan, not overborrowing and opening it at the right time to potentially qualify for some specific tax benefits. By making these four smart home equity moves now, borrowers can better position themselves for financial success both in today’s cooling rate climate and over the full repayment period.