CBS News
Makers of Coach and Michael Kors handbags blocked from merger in antitrust case
A U.S. District judge has halted the merger between the makers of Coach and Michael Kors handbags, saying it would reduce competition and hurt consumers.
In her ruling Thursday, U.S. District Judge Jennifer Rochon noted that Tapestry Inc. and Capri Holdings are “close competitors” and that the merger would result in “the loss of head-to-head competition” and raise prices for shoppers.
The decision followed seven days of testimony.
In after hours trading shares of Capri fell more than 50% while shares of Tapestry rose 12%.
The ruling came six months after the FTC sued to block Tapestry’s $8.5 billion acquisition of Capri, saying that the deal would eliminate direct competition between the fashion companies’ brands like Coach and Michael Kors in the so-called affordable luxury handbag arena.
The agency also said that the deal announced in August 2023 threatens to eliminate the incentive for the two companies to vie for employees and could depress employees’ wages and workplace benefits. The combined Tapestry and Capri would employ roughly 33,000 people worldwide, the agency said.
The two companies’ brands cover a wide array of items from clothing to eyewear to shoes. Tapestry has been on an acquisition binge for the past several years, and already owns Kate Spade New York, Stuart Weitzman and Coach. Capri owns the Versace, Michael Kors and Jimmy Choo brands.
Specifically, Tapestry’s Coach and Kate Spade brands and Capri’s Michael Kors brand are close rivals in the handbag market. The FTC had said that they continuously monitor each other’s handbag brands to determine pricing and performance, and they each use that information to make strategic decisions, including whether to raise or reduce handbag prices.
Tapestry said in an emailed statement to The Associated Press on Thursday that the decision granting the FTC’s request for a preliminary injunction was “disappointing” and “incorrect on the law and the facts.”
“Tapestry and Capri operate in an industry that is intensely competitive and dynamic, constantly expanding, and highly fragmented among both established players and new entrants,'” Tapestry said in a statement. “We face competitive pressures from both lower- and higher-priced products and continue to believe this transaction is pro-competitive and pro-consumer. “
The company said it intends to appeal the decision, consistent with its obligations under the merger agreement.
Capri could not be immediately reached for comment.
Neil Saunders, managing director of GlobalData, said in a published note that the blocking of Tapestry’s acquisition of Capri will come as a blow to both companies.
“For Tapestry, it puts an end to the goal of becoming a bigger house of brands, and it leaves its plans for future growth in tatters,” he said. He noted that in a slower market, Tapestry will now need to rely on pushing its existing brands harder, which he believes will be challenging. He noted that the group could, in time, also look to make smaller acquisitions.
The ruling leaves Capri “in poor shape and, in betting on being acquired, has neglected the hard work that needs to be done to course correct many of its weak brands,” Saunders said.
Capri will either need to find another party to buy it or it will have to embark on a major reinvention plan, he said.
CBS News
Alexander McCartney sentenced in U.K. court for “catfishing” thousands, including U.S. girl who died by suicide
A Northern Ireland man was sentenced Friday to a minimum of 20 years in prison after being found guilty by a U.K. court in what has been described as the biggest criminal “catfishing” case in the country. Alex McCartney, 26, had pleaded guilty earlier this year to a charge of manslaughter in a Northern Ireland court after a young American girl who was among the thousands of alleged victims he blackmailed online died by suicide.
McCartney had admitted to a total of 185 charges involving 70 child victims in court — including blackmail, inciting a child to engage in sexual activity and producing and distributing indecent images of children. He was also held culpable for the death of 12-year-old Cimarron Thomas in West Virginia, according to the U.K.’s Press Association news agency.
Thomas, who lived in West Virginia with her mother, father and siblings, died of suicide in May 2018. During her online interactions with McCartney, authorties say he attempted to coerce her into sending graphic images involving a younger sibling.
Courtesy of the family of Cimarron Thomas
McCartney was already under investigation at the time, and was about to face charges from British investigators when authorities discovered Cimarron’s identity and the circumstances of her death, CBS News’ partner network BBC News reported Friday.
Thomas’ father, a U.S. Army veteran, died by suicide 18 months after his daughter, not knowing any of the circumstances behind Cimarron’s death.
Jim Gamble, a former senior British police officer specializing in child safety, told BBC News that it was a “shocking case.”
“The sheer scale of it and the horrific nature of the harm inflicted on these young girls makes it one of the worst I’ve ever seen,” Gamble said, adding: “Don’t watch this and think this happens very rarely.”
Detective Chief Superintendent Eamonn Corrigan of the Police Service of Northern Ireland’s Crime Operations Department issued a statement Friday, calling McCartney “nothing but a disgusting child predator who was posing as young girls online to groom, manipulate and sexually abuse his victims, as young as four, to satisfy his own sexual perversions and that of other online child sexual offenders.”
Northern Ireland Police handout
McCartney’s crimes occurred between 2014 and 2019, when he’s believed by police to have targeted about 3,500 victims, mostly via Snapchat, all over the world, including in Australia, New Zealand and the U.S., according to the Press Association. The case against him in the Belfast Crown Court focused on 70 child victims, including Thomas.
There was no immediate response to Friday’s verdict against McCartney from Snapchat. The social messaging app was accused in September of having features that make it a favored platform of sexual criminals targeting children, in a lawsuit filed by New Mexico against its parent company, Snap Inc.
An undercover investigation by the state found Snapchat has crafted “an environment where predators can easily target children through sextortion schemes and other forms of sexual abuse,” Attorney General Raúl Torrez said in a news release.
In a statement responding to the New Mexico case, Snap said the app was designed “as a place to communicate with a close circle of friends, with built-in safety guardrails,” and it said there were “deliberate design choices to make it difficult for strangers to discover minors on our service.”
“We continue to evolve our safety mechanisms and policies, from leveraging advanced technology to detect and block certain activity, to prohibiting friending from suspicious accounts, to working alongside law enforcement and government agencies, among so much more,” the company said, adding that it continued to work with “industry, government, and law enforcement to exchange information and concept stronger defenses.”
Getty Images
While interest rates on traditional borrowing products like credit cards and personal loans are high right now – as they’ve been for much of the last few years – rates on home equity loans and home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) are in the single digits. And those rates could fall further if the Federal Reserve issues additional interest rate cuts to follow up on its September reduction. Combined with the knowledge that the average homeowner has approximately $330,000 in home equity right now, it’s understandable if borrowers are considering turning to home equity loans to help make ends meet.
But while there are timely benefits to using a home equity loan right now, there are also some significant risks that borrowers should be aware of heading into November. Below, we’ll break down three important ones to know before right now.
See what home equity loan rate you could qualify for here.
3 home equity loan risks to know this November
Home equity loans can benefit a wide swath of homeowners, but there are some inherent risks to the product that they should navigate around this November. Specifically, they should know that:
Interest rates could drop
Interest rates on home equity loans could and likely will fall in November if the Fed proceeds with another anticipated rate cut. That’s an advantage, on paper, but it means that the rate you secure earlier in the month may not be as low as what’s readily available later in November or in December. And you won’t be able to take advantage because home equity loan rates are fixed and will need to be refinanced to secure a lower rate. In this climate, then, a HELOC, which comes with variable interest rates subject to change monthly may be better. A HELOC will likely have lower rates — and, thus, lower payments — for multiple months to come as interest rates decline.
You may have an extra expense
As noted, home equity loan rates could drop, perhaps by a significant margin, after you’ve already opened a loan. You’ll then need to refinance to secure that newer rate and that will come at a cost. Home equity loan refinancing typically costs 1% to 5% of the total loan value. And if you’re taking out a significant amount of equity, that could prove to be a costly expense. To avoid this extra expense, then, it’s again worth considering a HELOC. HELOC rates adjust independently with no action — or expense — required on behalf of the borrower.
You may be tempted to overborrow
As mentioned above, the average home equity amount is closing in on $330,000 right now. That’s a lot of money to utilize, particularly at a relatively low interest rate. Knowing this, it may be tempting to overborrow right now. But that would be a mistake. Your home functions as collateral when borrowing home equity from a lender. And, if you withdraw too much and can’t repay your debt, you could risk losing your home in the process. So calculate your exact needs and borrow only that much with a home equity loan. If you don’t know precisely how much you need to borrow, consider a HELOC, which has more flexibility and works similarly to a revolving line of credit like a credit card.
The bottom line
Home equity loans offer unique benefits for borrowers, even now (they have slightly lower rates than HELOCs currently). But there are some timely risks to know this November, too, like the potential to get locked in at a higher rate as the overall rate climate cools, the extra expense of having to refinance and the temptation to overborrow via one lump sum. By understanding these risks and working around them via alternatives like HELOCs, home equity users can better position themselves for financial success, both in November and for the long term.
Have more questions? Learn more about home equity loans and HELOCs here.
Watch CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
If wires come down in your backyard, who do you call?
Alexander McCartney sentenced in U.K. court for “catfishing” thousands, including U.S. girl who died by suicide
STEP Academy faces smaller deficit than charter school first reported
If wires come down in your backyard, who do you call?
Alexander McCartney sentenced in U.K. court for “catfishing” thousands, including U.S. girl who died by suicide