CBS News
What Biden told then-special counsel Robert Hur in their 5-hour interview, according to the transcript
When then-special counsel Robert Hur released his February report on President Biden’s handling of classified material, Hur assessed that a jury wouldn’t be likely to convict Mr. Biden because he’d be seen as a “well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.” That single line in the 345-page report delighted Republicans and infuriated the president and his allies, even though Hur cleared the president of criminal wrongdoing.
The transcript of Hur’s interview with Mr. Biden last October, reviewed by CBS News, provides a fuller picture of the five-hour conversation between the two and context around some of the statements that appeared in the report. It reflects a professional, polite and occasionally humorous mood in the room.
President Biden said he was largely unaware of how classified government records from his decades-long career in public office ended up in his homes and private office, according to the transcript.
In the interview, Hur commended Mr. Biden’s “significant cooperation” with the investigation and asked the president for his “best recollection in response” to questions. “I acknowledge that some of the questions we are asking relate to events that happened years ago,” Hur said.
“I’m a young man, so it’s not a problem,” Mr. Biden joked, according to the transcript.
Hur noted in his report that Mr. Biden, then 80, struggled to recall the date that his son Beau died of brain cancer. This angered the president, and in speaking with the press about Hur’s report soon after its release, Mr. Biden said, “How in the hell dare he raise that. Frankly, when I was asked the question, I thought to myself it wasn’t any of their damn business.”
The transcript of Hur’s interview with Mr. Biden shows the president unable to identify the precise year — but that he correctly named the month and date.
“What month did Beau die? Oh God — May 30th,” Mr. Biden asks the room.
A White House lawyer responds, “2015.”
“Was it 2015 he had died?” the president asks.
An unidentified person in the room replies, “It was May of 2015.”
Mr. Biden agrees. “It was 2015,” he said.
He also misstates the year former President Donald Trump was elected and questions which year his own vice presidency ended. Mr. Biden is quickly corrected by attorneys in the room. Throughout the interview, Mr. Biden appears to be reaching for words he cannot find. Twice, the phrase “fax machine” eludes him, and he confuses Iraq and Afghanistan for Iran.
The missteps appear to be common lapses for Mr. Biden who for years has struggled with names and dates in public speaking engagements.
Hur is scheduled to testify before the House Judiciary Committee on Tuesday. His role at the Justice Department ended once he filed his report in early February, which determined that “the evidence does not establish Mr. Biden’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Mr. Biden told investigators he was uninvolved with the details and logistics of packing and moving his offices. That work was left almost entirely to staff, he said.
“I didn’t pay any attention to how they packed it up,” Mr. Biden told Hur about moving out of the Naval Observatory in early 2017. Mr. Biden added that he didn’t “have any idea” which files were in the West Wing office. “I let them decide where things would go.”
“My generic problem was there was a lot of stuff,” the president said.
Over two days in October last year, Mr. Biden and a team of lawyers sat for the interviews with special counsel Hur and his investigators in the White House Map Room. Hur led the questioning, probing the president on how his vice presidential residence and offices were packed in 2017 and how the material was transported and eventually stored at his homes in Virginia and Delaware.
Documents marked classified were found in Biden’s Wilmington, Delaware, garage and home office. Biden said some were dropped in his driveway after he moved out of his Virginia rental home and the Penn Biden Center office space in Washington, D.C.
Hur asked whether boxes shown in a photo of his garage corresponded to the boxes left in the driveway.
“I have no goddamn idea,” Biden said.
Mr. Biden joked with Hur about his habit of tossing decades’ worth of papers, photos and memorabilia in filing cabinets and never looking at them again.
Notebooks containing classified material were stashed haphazardly in his Wilmington home. “I wish I could say I was more organized,” Mr. Biden admits, but says he was unaware they contained anything restricted.
“If I had written notes in my book, they’re my notes and my property,” Mr. Biden told Hur. They are mine…and every president before me has done the same exact thing.”
The interview, conducted on Oct. 8 and 9, came immediately following the Hamas attack on Israel, which Hur acknowledged. “I know there are a lot of other things in the world going on that demand your attention,” Hur said.
Mr. Biden began the second day of the interview with a clarification of his comments from day one: “I didn’t keep anything that wasn’t — [that] I thought was classified.”
Hur asks Mr. Biden specifically about a statement he made to Mark Zwonitzer, the ghostwriter assisting with his memoir. Investigators recovered a recording of Mr. Biden telling Zwonitzer in 2017, he “just found all the classified stuff downstairs.”
Mr. Biden said he had no memory of that comment which was made in reference to a 2009 memo he had written to then-President Barack Obama regarding Afghanistan. An original copy of that memo, which contained classified information, was found in Mr. Biden’s garage.
“I had no purpose for [keeping classified documents], and I think it would be inappropriate for me to keep clearly classified documents….I had no authority to have them,” after leaving the vice presidency, Biden said, unaware that he had retained the handwritten memo.
The president, over the course of his interview, also goes on lengthy digressions about trips he’s taken abroad, a case he handled in private practice when he was just out of law school, electric cars and eulogies he’s delivered over the years. They are some of the same stories he tells on the stump.
During a tale about why he never seriously invested in the stock market as a senator, Biden replied, “The thing I valued most my whole life — my reputation and integrity.”
CBS News
Here’s how much more it will cost to heat your home this winter
Americans are expected to spend more money heating their homes this winter than on holiday gifts, according to new research.
The elevated cost of staying warm indoors amid cold outdoor temperatures comes after an unusually hot summer, that led to households spending bigger shares of their budgets on cooling costs, compared with previous years, according to a report from the National Energy Assistance Directors Association (NEADA).
On average, spending on home heating this winter is projected to increase by 8.7% to $941, up from $866 last winter. The increased costs are attributed in part to both expected colder temperatures in the Northeast and Midwest states.
The new average expenditure on heating costs outpaces the $902 the average household is expected to spend on Christmas presents this year, according to a forecast from the National Retail Federation.
What’s driving up home heating costs?
There are different ways to keep residences warm. Families that use electricity to heat their homes are expected to face the largest increase in costs — more than 14% — which will bring the total up to $1,189 from $1,040 from mid-November through mid-March, which NEADA considers to be the winter period.
Driving up prices is the rising cost of updating and maintaining the electric grid. Plus, colder weather is expected to lead to increased consumption.
“It’s colder, and the cost of electricity is up as the grid is rebuilt. So we’re seeing both higher prices and greater usage,” NEADA Executive Director Mark Wolfe told CBS MoneyWatch.
Natural gas, propane and heating oil cost differences
Natural gas and propane users are also expected to be hit with bigger bills this winter. Heating costs for natural gas are up just over 3%, for an average cost of $634 for the winter period, compared with $615 for 2023-2024. Costs are expected to rise only modestly in line with wholesale prices.
Propane costs are up 4.4%, with families expected to spend an average of $1,231 heating homes, up from $1,179 last season.
Heating oil costs, by contrast, have declined 2.7%, which means average spending this winter will be $1,518, down from $1,560 last winter.
Early start to the season
November was colder than usual, with temperatures dropping prematurely after a “very expensive summer” of heat waves straining cooling resources, said Wolfe.
Blame climate change for the big swings in temperature, he added.
“Weather conditions can be very unpredictable even though over time, winters are getting warmer and summers are getting hotter. It’s not a straight line, and for consumers, it’s quite upsetting because higher utility bills are coming right before Christmas,” Wolfe said.
Steps to take now
There are steps consumers can take to help keep a lid on home heating costs.
Wolfe urges people to have their thermostats serviced now, before the coldest temperatures of the season roll in. That way, families won’t be on the hook for an emergency repair if their thermostat breaks in the middle of a cold front. A tune-up will also help heating systems run more efficiently, he said.
Always close the furnace flue, or else it will lead heat outside the house, advises Wolfe. Lastly, manually turn down the heat at night, if you can, to save up to 10% on your energy bill.
CBS News
The Pager Plot | Sunday on 60 Minutes
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
CBS News
Mega Millions jackpot soars to $862 million for Friday night’s drawing
There’s still time to become a mega-millionaire for Christmas, but lady luck will have to be on your side.
No one matched Mega Millions‘ all six winning numbers last Tuesday, and the jackpot now stands at $862 million ahead of Friday night’s drawing.
The jackpot has been rolling since it was last won at $810 million in Texas on Sept. 10.
If there is a sole winner, they have a choice between an annuity, with an initial payment and then 29 annual payments, or a one-time lump sum payment. Most winners choose a cash payout.
For Friday night’s drawing, that would be an estimated $392.1 million before taxes.
If won at that level, it would be the largest prize ever won in December and the seventh largest in Mega Millions history.
According to Mega Millions, 13 jackpots have been won during December since the game began in 2002. Three were won in the days after Christmas, while the other 10 were won before Christmas. There has never been a jackpot win on Christmas Day, although over the years drawings have been conducted on Christmas six times – in 2007, 2009, 2012, 2015, 2018 and 2020.
Mega Millions drawings are held on Tuesday and Friday, tickets cost $2. The odds of winning the jackpot are about 1 in 303 million.