CBS News
Trump sues CBS News over 60 Minutes interview with Harris; network says suit is “completely without merit”
Former President Donald Trump has sued CBS News, alleging the network’s “deceitful” editing of a recent 60 Minutes interview with Vice President Kamala Harris misled the public and unfairly disadvantaged him.
In a statement released Thursday, CBS News called the former president’s claims “completely without merit” and said the network intended to vigorously defend against the lawsuit.
The lawsuit, which comes just days before the two candidates face off in the 2024 presidential election, centers on two clips of an October interview 60 Minutes conducted with Harris. One of the clips was edited to include a longer section of her response to a question about the conflict in the Middle East. Trump’s lawsuit contends this editing decision was meant to intentionally assist his opponent and mislead the public, something CBS News has disputed.
“To paper over Kamala’s ‘word salad’ weakness, CBS used its national platform on 60 Minutes to cross the line from the exercise of judgment in reporting to deceitful, deceptive manipulation of news,” the lawsuit claims. The suit says the former president seeks a jury trial and at least $10 billion in damages.
“Former President Trump’s repeated claims against 60 Minutes are false,” the network statement says. “The Interview was not doctored.”
Trump’s legal complaint was filed Thursday in federal court in the Northern District of Texas Amarillo division, a remote venue where the lone judge is a 2019 Trump appointee. Republican-led states and special interest groups have directed at least 14 politically sensitive cases to that court since January 2021, according to progressive watchdog group Accountable.US.
The lawsuit does not claim Trump was defamed by the network, said Geoffrey R. Stone, a First Amendment scholar and law professor at the University of Chicago, who reviewed the complaint. Instead, the suit attempts a novel use of a Texas statute that is meant to prevent advertisers from misleading the public about a product being sold — the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Consumer Protection Act.
Stone called it a “misapplication” of the law.
“That statute is about sales — a salesperson can be held liable for stating that a product has certain positive effects when he knows it doesn’t,” Stone said. “But CBS is not engaged in advertising here.”
Harvard Law Professor Noah Feldman, a constitutional law expert, said he was mystified by the Trump claims and called the case an “outrageous violation of First Amendment principles.”
“This is a complaint so ill grounded that it comes close to being sanctionable as frivolous,” Feldman said.
The former president has for weeks been voicing his displeasure about the interview on the campaign trail.
“Millions of Americans, including residents of Texas and this District, were confused and misled by the two doctored Interview versions,” the suit alleges.
In an earlier statement released by 60 Minutes, the network explained the two clips were edited differently because one segment, which appeared on “Face the Nation,” afforded more time to accommodate a longer section of Harris’s answer.
“Same question. Same answer. But a different portion of the response,” the Oct. 20 statement from 60 Minutes said. “When we edit any interview, whether a politician, an athlete, or movie star, we strive to be clear, accurate and on point. The portion of her answer on 60 Minutes was more succinct, which allows time for other subjects in a wide ranging 21-minute-long segment.”
Trump had been invited to sit for his own interview on 60 Minutes but declined.
The former president has previously filed several lawsuits against media organizations, including a March defamation case against ABC News over a question asked by anchor George Stephanopoulos during an interview.
He has lost prior defamation lawsuits against CNN, The Washington Post and The New York Times.
CBS News
11/1: CBS Evening News – CBS News
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
CBS News
From the archives: British PM Margaret Thatcher joins Face the Nation
Be the first to know
Get browser notifications for breaking news, live events, and exclusive reporting.
CBS News
Maui surfer loses part of leg in shark attack, officials say
A shark bit a Maui surfer Friday morning and severed his leg, authorities said.
The man, 61, was surfing off Waiehu Beach Park Friday morning in a surf spot known as Sand Piles when a shark bit him,” Maui County said in a news release.
Police officers who arrived to the scene first tried to control the bleeding with tourniquets. His leg was “completely severed just below the knee,” officials said.
Witnesses told CBS affiliate Hawaii News Now that other surfers helped the man swim back to shore.
“I heard this yell and I looked, and all of a sudden I just seen him splash, and I don’t know what was happening,” witness David Basques told Hawaii News Now. “…He swam himself back maybe more than half the way, and then I seen somebody jump in and they went bring him inside.”
The man was alert while being treated on shore and then taken to Maui Memorial Medical Center in critical condition.
“I would like to commend the patient for his strength and wherewithal, getting himself to shore,” Maui Fire Department Assistant Chief Jeff Giesea told reporters, according to KGMB. “I mean, that’s extraordinary. Whatever Good Samaritans offered assistance, I’d like to commend them as well.”
The incident prompted officials to close the beach park. Officials warned people to stay out of the water in the area. The public warning to stay out of the water for a mile in each direction of the incident will be in effect until at least noon Saturday. The warning will be extended if there is a shark sighting in the area.
Maui fire and ocean safety officials were patrolling the waters using rescue watercraft and a drone. State officials provided shark warning signs and helped with cordoning off the area.
There were no details provided on what kind of shark was involved.
In June, well-known surfer Tamayo Perry was killed in a shark attack while surfing off Oahu’s North Shore.