CBS News
New Mexico man awarded $412 million payout over botched penile injections: “A national record-setting case”
Jurors in New Mexico have awarded a man more than $412 million in a medical malpractice case that involved a men’s health clinic that operates in several states.
The man’s attorneys celebrated Monday’s verdict, saying they are hopeful it will prevent other men from falling victim to a scheme that involved fraud and what they described as dangerous penile injections. They said the punitive and compensatory damages total the largest amount to ever be awarded by a jury in a medical malpractice case in the U.S.
“It’s a national record-setting case and it’s righteous because I don’t think there’s any place for licensed professionals to be defrauding patients for money. That is a very egregious breach of their fiduciary duty,” said Lori Bencoe, one of the lawyers who represented the plaintiff. “That’s breach of trust and anytime someone is wearing a white coat, they shouldn’t be allowed to do that.”
The award follows a trial held in Albuquerque earlier this month that centered on allegations outlined in a lawsuit filed by the man’s attorneys in 2020. NuMale Medical Center and company officials were named as defendants.
“This corporate scheme manipulates and uses fear as a tactic to convince these men to do this,” Nick Rowley, a trial lawyer, told CBS affiliate KRQE.
According to the complaint, the man was 66 when he visited the clinic in 2017 in search of treatment for fatigue and weight loss. The clinic is accused of misdiagnosing him and unnecessarily treating him with “invasive erectile dysfunction shots” that caused irreversible damage.
Nick Rowley, another attorney who was part of the plaintiff’s team, said the out-of-state medical corporation set up a “fraudulent scheme to make millions off of conning old men.” He provided some details in a social media post, saying clinic workers told patients they would have irreversible damage if they didn’t agree to injections three times a week.
NuMale Medical Center told KRQE that they “disagree with the verdict and intend to pursue all available legal remedies, including appeal.”
NuMale Medical Center President Brad Palubicki said in a statement sent Wednesday to The Associated Press that the company’s focus is on continuing to deliver responsible patient care while maintaining strict safety and compliance standards at all of its facilities.
“While we respect the judicial process, due to ongoing legal proceedings, we cannot comment on specific details of the case at this time,” he said.
NuMale also has clinics in Colorado, Florida, Illinois, Nevada, Nebraska, North Carolina and Wisconsin.
According to court records, jurors found that fraudulent and negligent conduct by the defendants resulted in damages to the plaintiff. They also found that unconscionable conduct by the defendants violated the Unfair Practices Act.
In a statement to KRQE, the man’s attorneys said the verdict sends a powerful message that “medical providers cannot prioritize profits over patients’ well-being without being held accountable.”
CBS News
Bidens spending last Thanksgiving as president on Nantucket, a family tradition
President Biden, first lady Jill Biden and members of their family are spending his final Thanksgiving holiday as president on Nantucket, per family tradition.
Mr. Biden headed to a fire station on Nantucket, as he has in previous years. The family is staying at the house of billionaire David Rubenstein, where they have stayed for the past three years.
This year, daughter Ashley Biden and son Hunter Biden traveled with Mr. Biden and the first lady. Hunter’s wife Melissa and their 4-year-old son Beau, Jr. also traveled with them and there may be other family members staying with the Bidens.
Start of Biden family Nantucket tradition
The Biden family has been celebrating Thanksgiving in Nantucket for over 40 years. Mr. Biden wrote in his memoir “Promise Me, Dad,” that “we had some great years in that span, and we had some lousy years, but whatever was happening, whatever bumps and bruises we were suffering, we put it all aside and celebrated Thanksgiving in Nantucket.”
Jill Biden wrote in her memoir “Where the Light Enters,” that the Bidens started going to Nantucket when she and the president started dating.
“When Thanksgiving rolled around, we knew we wanted to spend it together, but we didn’t know where,” she writes. “My parents wanted us to join them, his parents wanted us to join them, and even Neilia’s parents had extended an invitation. We were touched and grateful, but it was stressful to think about choosing one family gathering over another, so I said to Joe, ‘Let’s go somewhere, just the four of us.'”
Jill Biden said that her husband’s then-chief of staff suggested Nantucket, which neither of them had ever been, but she said they decided “it sounded as good as anywhere.”
“I packed a cooler with sandwiches and sodas, we loaded the boys into a station wagon and we drove six hours to the Cape,” she writes. “On a packed ferryboat to the island, we chugged past beautiful Brant Point Lighthouse and up to the pier. Joe and I took deep breaths of salt-tinged air as we got our first view of the shingled cottages that lined the coast … That first year, we stayed in one of those cottages, right on the water, paying one hundred dollars for the whole week.”
Jill Biden writes that Nantucket Thanksgiving became the family tradition for the next four decades. “With a few exceptions, we’ve made the trek every year since, creating rituals that would become a key part of our family along the way,” she writes.
“Once in Nantucket, we spend hours poking around in the shops, and on the Friday after Thanksgiving, we go to the Brotherhood of Thieves restaurant for lunch. We gather on cobblestoned Main Street on Friday evenings to see Santa Claus, watch the big Christmas tree-lighting ceremony, and sing carols. And for many years, we posed for a family photo in front of a charming seaside cottage with the sign in front that read: FOREVER WILD.”
Mr. Biden’s late son Beau proposed to his wife Hallie at the annual Christmas tree lighting in 2001 and they were married at Nantucket’s St. Mary’s church the following year.
“Hallie always suspected it was Beau’s way of locking them into Biden Family Thanksgivings for all time,” Mr. Biden wrote. “And it worked. They were celebrating their twelfth anniversary at the end of the week, and Hallie had never missed a Thanksgiving. Even the year Beau was stationed in Iraq, she insisted we all keep the tradition and go to Nantucket.”
“The holiday trip was a constant in our grandchildren’s lives from the time they were aware, and they made it clear how much it meant to them,” Mr. Biden wrote.
Mr. Biden’s fateful conversation about the future with Beau and Hunter
Mr. Biden wrote in “Promise Me, Dad,” that during Thanksgiving weekend in 2014, with Beau suffering from brain cancer, his decision about the 2016 presidential race weighed heavily on his mind.
Mr. Biden wrote that in the kitchen in Nantucket, Beau told him “Dad, you’ve got it wrong … you’ve got to run. I want you to run.” He said Hunter agreed. “The three of us talked for an hour,” he wrote.
Mr. Biden ultimately decided not to run that cycle, and Beau Biden died on May 30, 2015 — making that year the last year the whole family spent the holiday together on Nantucket.
“No Thanksgiving would ever be the same,” Mr. Biden wrote.
Bidens return to Nantucket
Jill Biden wrote that in 2015, the family went to Rome instead of Nantucket. “Nantucket was just another place to remind us of all that we had lost, like a photograph with Beau’s face cut out.”
But she wrote that their grandkids asked to return in 2016. “Thanksgiving was Nantucket. They missed the little shops, the ice cream parlor we always visited, the traditional Friday lunch. They wanted to watch the Christmas tree lighting and wander the cobblestone streets. They wanted to be together. To feel normal again.”
She wrote that they all “easily fell back into their old routines.”
Nantucket, she wrote, was “where we learned how to be a family — all the complicated story lines of birth and death, marriage and divorce, hurt and healing, love and love and love, coming together in this little town at the edge of the world.”
Nantucket’s reaction to the Bidens
Jill Biden wrote in her memoir that when they drove down Main Street in 2016, store windows were flooded with signs saying “Welcome back, Bidens!”
According to the Nantucket Current, “residents have grown accustomed to over the past three years during Biden’s presidency” that “downtown hotels and inns are fully booked with Secret Service personnel, security teams, and White House reporters during what is normally a quiet holiday for the island.”
“Over the past three days, massive Air Force C-17s were flying in and out of the airport dropping off vehicles and equipment, while nearly a dozen Massachusetts State Police Troopers arrived on motorcycles aboard the Steamship Authority ferry on Monday,” the Nantucket Current said. “Meanwhile at Faregrounds Restaurant, chef Bill Puder is cooking up more than 200 turkey dinners for the Secret Service.”
Traffic and security advisories have been listed for the Christmas tree lighting on Friday. In previous years, they have participated in the Polar Bear Plunge on Friday as well.
CBS News
Canada weighing how to retaliate if Trump imposes 25% tariffs
Experts say a volley of tariffs between the U.S. and Canada could tip both countries into a recession and severely disrupt cross-border commerce between the key trading partners.
A Canadian government official said Wednesday it is exploring potential retaliatory levies on certain U.S. imports after President-elect Donald Trump on Monday threatened to impose a 25% tariff on all goods from Canada and Mexico on his first day in office. The official, who stressed no final decision has been taken, spoke on condition of anonymity as they were not authorized to speak publicly.
Mexican President Claudia Sheinbaum earlier this week also hinted that the country could retaliate against the U.S. with its own tariffs on American products. Trump said the stepped-up duties are necessary to curb the flow of undocumented immigrants and illicit drugs from Mexico and Canada.
“Blanket 25% tariffs on Canada threatened by U.S. President-elect Donald Trump earlier this week would push Canada into a recession in 2025, cause a sharp spike in inflation and force the Bank of Canada to hold rates higher next year,” economist Michael Davenport of Oxford Economics said in a report Thursday.
Inflation in Canada would top 7% by mid-2025, while unemployment would approach 8% by year-end, according to the investment research firm. The country’s auto, energy and heavy manufacturing industries, which rely on exports to the U.S., would take the biggest hit, he added, noting that the sectors also depend on components from American suppliers.
Canada fired back with duties of its own when Trump slapped tariffs on the country’s steel and aluminum exports to the U.S. during his first stint in the White House. Canada targeted U.S. products including whiskey and yogurt, most of which came from one plant in Wisconsin, home state of then-House Speaker Paul Ryan.
Canadian officials say lumping Canada in with Mexico is unfair but say they are ready to make new investments in border security and work with the Trump administration to lower the numbers from Canada. The Canadians are also worried about an influx of migrants if Trump follows through with his plan for mass deportations.
U.S. also would feel the pain
Trump and his allies, including his choice for Treasury Secretary, Scott Bessent, have argued that tariffs deployed during his first term advanced U.S. economic aims and didn’t boost inflation.
But the U.S. likely wouldn’t go unscathed in a full-blown trade war with Canada. Across-the-board tariffs on American products would likely cause a “shallow” recession in the U.S. and fracture political relations between the allies, according to Oxford.
Although the U.S. is the world’s leading oil producer, Canada supplies roughly 20% of the oil used stateside. As a result, U.S. gas prices could shoot up 30 to 40 cents a gallon, and potentially up to 70 cents, soon after Trump levied the tariffs on Canada, Patrick De Haan, head of petroleum analysis at GasBuddy, told CBS MoneyWatch.
With so much on the line, the incoming Trump administration is more likely to impose limited tariffs on Canadian products, such as steel, lumber and farm products like dairy.
“Despite Trump’s latest threat of blanket tariffs, we still think it’s unlikely that the Trump administration will put tariffs on Canadian autos and energy exports, which make up about 40% of total Canadian exports to the U.S.,” Davenport said. “The North American energy sector and auto supply chains are highly integrated across the U.S.-Canada border and any tariffs on these goods would also have a significant negative effect on the US economy.”
contributed to this report.
CBS News
Doctor suspected of killing 8 patients in Berlin and setting fires to cover up crimes: “Lust for murder”
German investigators suspect a Berlin doctor of killing eight elderly patients under his care and setting fire to some of their homes to cover up his crimes, prosecutors said Thursday.
The suspect, a 40-year-old whose identity has not been released, worked in palliative care for an at-home nursing service.
He was remanded in custody in August on suspicion of killing four women aged 72 to 94, and Berlin prosecutors have now linked him to four more deaths of men and women aged 61 to 83.
Police in August said the man was being investigated on four counts of manslaughter, one count of arson and three counts of attempted arson.
Berlin prosecutors said they were now treating the alleged killings as murder cases.
“The accused appears to have had no motive for killing the people other than the act of killing itself,” they said, accusing him of a “lust for murder.”
Police in August said the man was suspected of killing four female patients in the care of his nursing service in Berlin between June 11 and July 24.
In one case, an 87-year-old woman was resuscitated after emergency services arrived, but died later in hospital.
In another, the suspect allegedly started a blaze but the fire went out.
“When he realized this, he allegedly informed a relative of the woman and claimed that he was standing in front of her flat and that nobody was answering the doorbell,” police said.
In the four new cases, which date from June 2022 to April 2024, the suspect is accused of killing two men and two women in Berlin.
In one case, he is suspected of administering a cocktail of medications to a 70-year-old woman in her apartment in Berlin’s Tempelhof district and then starting a fire.
The fire department, called by a neighbor, was able to prevent the flames from spreading to the rest of the building.
He is also accused of administering deadly medications to two men, aged 70 and 83, and to a 61-year-old woman.
The case recalls that of the notorious German nurse Niels Hoegel, who was sentenced in 2019 to life in prison for murdering 85 patients in his care.
Hoegel, believed to be Germany’s most prolific serial killer, murdered hospital patients with lethal injections between 2000 and 2005, before he was eventually caught in the act.
A former colleague told the German newspaper Bild that Högel was nicknamed “Resuscitation Rambo” because of the way he “pushed everyone else aside” when patients needed to be resuscitated, the BBC reported.
In a more recent case, a 27-year-old male nurse was sentenced to life in prison in 2023 for murdering two patients by deliberately administering unprescribed drugs.
The nurse, identified as Mario G., was also found guilty on six counts of attempted murder.
During his trial, Mario G. admitted to injecting patients with sedatives and other drug cocktails while working in the recovery room at a Munich hospital.
The case in Berlin comes just weeks after a British doctor admitted posing as a nurse and trying to kill his mother’s long-term partner by injecting the man with poison disguised as a COVID-19 vaccine.
In August, a British judge sentenced nurse Lucy Letby to spend the rest of her life in prison for murdering seven babies and attempting to kill six others while working at a hospital in northern England.